Thursday, January 26, 2017

Episode #5: Should grade requirements be set for student athletes?

Topic: Grade Requirements for Student Athletes
Question:Should middle and high school students have a grade requirement to participate in sports?

In this episode we will be unpacking information about GPA requirements to play sports in middle and high school.  We will also be asking our guests some questions on this topic. Listen as your host, Jimmy Allon, speaks with guest expert Professor Brown, Calvin Crien, and Tom McMuffin. What will you decide?


Sources:

SERP, Harvard. (2015). Should student athletes have to meet grade requirements  to participate in sports. Word Generation. www.wordgeneration.org


Bowman, Sarah. (2014).
GPA requirements for student athletes are proving successful. Beaufort Gazette. http://www.islandpacket.com




Lavigne, Paula. (2016) Bad Grades? Some Schools OK with It. ESPN.


6 comments:

  1. I liked that Professor Brown mentioned some schools 6th grade sport requirements. They also covered many questions and open ideas about the topic. They also supplied good and interesting facts. But the one thing that I am still questioning is what is the average grade requirement for middle school sports. Although I agree with both sides I do not agree with your consensus. I don't agree with your consensus because if kids don't have good grades going for them then they are most likely going to not be successful in life. Very very little people make it to the NFL so they can't rely on that.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like how your interviewee’s information really tried to get people to join their side. For example when interviewee 1 said that not only hurt him/her not being able to play, but it will also hurt the whole team. That kind of made me relize that this can affect more than just that one person. That was a big factor of deciding even though I went with the other side of having a grade requirement. It was a tough decision to decide,but I choose having a grade requirement because of a question/concern. The concern was that if there was a grade requirement, then students who didn't pass wouldn't be able to participate which would hurt the teammates. Though if there was no grade requirement and a student was failing, but went to sports, then how would a teacher feel that one of her students was not succeeding? I thought just a little bit different of the concluding statement just because I heard a little more facts for grade requirement rather then no grade requirement. Otherwise I could see how you got that with all the persuading from interviewee 1. This in my opinion was a great podcast.
    ~Ben McGilvray

    ReplyDelete
  3. Amazing job. I really liked how you showed the perspective of a coach and a teacher. There was good information but I think you could have put a little bit more background information. Both perspectives have great detail. My opinion on this question would be yes they should have grade requirements so that kids can focus on school and not just sports. Is there a side for students or parents?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I though that this podcast was good. I like that it included many quotes from actual coaches and teachers. I liked that they included important informations about deciding on whether or not on having grade requirements to play sports. I thought that it was interesting that star athletes are also effected by the grade requirements. I also thought that it was interesting that the grade requirement changes based on your grade. i thought that this was a good podcast overal.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The Grade Requirements Podcast was very interesting and exciting. They did a great job introducing the topic with how much money students would've been given. Also, both sides were represented well. I especially liked the way the second interviewee represented his case because he stated many facts. I agree with their final decision because students could be very athletic and good at sports, but may be not too smart. That isn't very fair to those people. I think it's ridiculous that some students are being paid for good grades.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really enjoyed the podcast that you made. I think people are not required to get good grades in order to play sports because some professional sports players never went to collage but they are still doing very well in life. I liked how there was many facts and opinions about this topic. For example if a player doesn't get good grades it could cost him or her team to not win. Everyone in your group did a great job on the podcast. I have a question to ask you "are professional sports players educated"?

    ReplyDelete

Episode #25: Play Ball!

Episode #25 Topic: Length of baseball games Question: Are baseball games too long? Did you know that the average baseball game is over...