Question: Should we experiment on the mummies and put them in museums or keep them in their coffins?
Did you know that King Tut was the youngest ruler in Egyptian history, and he was only 19 when he died? Historians know this from studying his remains. In this episode we discuss whether we should continue to study and display the human remains that scientists and explorers find, or let them be. Listen as your host, James Conway, speaks with guest expert Dr Tim, and interviews Professor Julian and Ash Grey to puzzle this out. What will you decide?
Our Sources:
1. SERP Harvard, 2015, Unit 1.11 Who owns the dead, Word Generation,
We use this source to introduce ourselves to the project.
2. Smithsonian information, 2012, Egyptian mummies, Smithsonian information, http://www.si.edu/Encyclopedia_SI/nmnh/mummies.htm
3. Kennedy, Maev,2010,museums avoid displaying human remains out of respect, www.theguardian.com, www.theguardian.com/culture, we use the source to find facts for our topic.
4. A and E networks, 2017,Tutankhame, History, http://www.history.com/topics/ancient-history/tutankhamen , we use the source to find facts about King Tut
5. San Diego Natural History Museum, 2017, The Discovery Of King Tut, The Nat, www.sdnhm.org/kingtut/.
6. Iac.publishing., 2017, https://www.reference.com/history/items-tools-were-used-mummify-people-ancient-egypt-4a53b42e4fb8d1c7# What items or tools were used to mummified people in ancient Egypt?
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteSomething I liked about this piece was how the flow went and how much detail they put. One question I still have after hearing this it how many mummies have scientists found? Lastly I agree that mummies should get researched.
I enjoyed listening to this podcast. It has just the right amount of background information on mummies and if they should be studied or not. I liked how you said that the organs are preserved in salt and other materials before covering the body in cloth and putting it in a tomb. Knowing what a mummy is, is important before deciding your side. You had a good amount of information, although I do feel there could be a little more from both sides. You had ten minutes, but only used 6 minutes and 3 seconds. I personally agree with the censensus made by the host and guest expert because we can learn more about them if we study them, but we will know nothing if they are stuck in a tomb. I would also like to know the names of any ther mummies that have been tested.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed listening to your podcast. It was very descriptive for information on the mummies and whether they should be studied. I liked when you explained what a mummy is by saying “A human mummy is any preserved human remains”. I think it was useful knowing what a mummy is before I heard the actual evidence. You had the perfect amount of information in this podcast, I also think it was the perfect length. I liked how you talked about how they studied King Tut’s mummy. This helped me understand what the benefits for studying mummies. My personal opinion is that they should study mummies. However, I was still wondering whether we should study everyone. I mean it could cost a lot of money and most of the time you won't learn much. So that is just something I am still wondering about mummies. Keep up the good work!
ReplyDeleteI think that this was a better podcast. It had just the right amount of detail without boring the listeners with facts. I also liked how you gave us background information on how mummies are classified and some famous mummies. At first I thought that we should not bother them because of science. My opinion might not have swayed, but this sure does have the right amount of details to move someone to either side.
ReplyDelete